Manufacturing Advisory Service: Optimizing Production Costs

---

Key Takeaways

• Quality costs run 15-20% of revenue: According to ASQ, many manufacturers fail to track prevention and appraisal costs—only capturing failure expenses like scrap and rework
• Workforce challenges impact margins: Nearly one-quarter of manufacturing workers are age 55+ and retiring, creating labor cost pressures that erode profitability
• Traditional costing methods fail: Standard overhead allocation models designed for single-product operations distort profitability in high-mix, low-volume environments
• Bottom Line: Production cost optimization requires building financial intelligence into operations so CEOs know exactly where value gets created and where margins disappear

Your manufacturing operation produces quality products. Your team hits production targets. Your customers are satisfied. And yet, when you look at your P&L, margins are thinner than they should be—and you can’t quite pinpoint why.

Welcome to the manufacturing profitability paradox: you’re running efficiently by traditional metrics, but your financial performance tells a different story. The problem isn’t manufacturing execution—it’s that standard cost accounting wasn’t designed to help you optimize modern production economics.

The Five Production Cost Killers Hiding in Your Operation

We’re here to clue you in on the secret cost killers.

1. Overhead Allocation That Distorts Profitability

Your ERP system allocates overhead based on labor hours or machine time, which worked for single-product, high-volume manufacturing. But if you’re running high-mix, low-volume production with varying complexity, those allocation methods create fiction.

What’s actually happening: Simple, high-volume products subsidize complex, custom orders. You’re pricing easy work too high (losing bids) and complicated work too low (winning unprofitable business).

Manufacturing advisory solution: Activity-based costing that captures true cost drivers—setup time, engineering changes, quality inspections, material handling, and customer-specific requirements. This reveals which products and customers actually generate profit.

2. Quality Costs Beyond the Rework Report

You track scrap and rework, but quality costs extend far beyond direct failure expenses. According to the American Society for Quality, total quality costs typically represent 15-20% of sales revenue. Many manufacturers, however, focus tracking efforts primarily on internal failure costs (scrap, rework) while underinvesting in prevention and appraisal activities.

The hidden costs: Customer inspections, engineering investigation time, expedited replacement materials, warranty claims, and the business development effort managing dissatisfied customers all erode margins—but often don’t appear in standard cost reports.

Manufacturing advisory insight: Comprehensive cost-of-quality tracking across prevention, appraisal, internal failure, and external failure categories reveals that investing $1 in prevention typically saves $5 to $ 10 in failure costs.

3. Material Waste That Doesn’t Hit the Cost Sheet

You monitor scrap rates, but do you capture the cost of overbuying to hedge against quality issues? Or expedited material premiums when production planning breaks down? Or inventory carrying costs for safety stock that exists because forecasting is unreliable?

The impact: Most manufacturers underestimate total material when including waste, obsolescence, and carrying costs—margin erosion that never shows up in standard reports.

Manufacturing advisory solution: True material cost tracking, including waste rates, inventory turns by SKU, and supplier quality metrics, consistently reveals opportunities to improve gross margins.

4. Labor Productivity Metrics That Drive Wrong Behaviors

Your direct labor efficiency could be 95%—but that metric may be meaningless. If operators are waiting for materials, running low-priority work to maintain efficiency numbers, or producing to forecast instead of actual demand, high efficiency masks value destruction.

The productivity illusion: Traditional efficiency metrics were designed for single-product operations. In modern manufacturing, where frequent changeovers and demand volatility are common, they often lead to counterproductive behaviors.

Manufacturing advisory approach: Measure productivity as value creation—throughput per constraint hour, on-time delivery performance, and contribution margin per labor dollar—rather than simple efficiency percentages.

5. Workforce Cost Pressures You Can’t Control

The National Association of Manufacturers reports that nearly one-quarter of the manufacturing workforce is age 55 or older. As experienced workers retire, replacement costs include not only higher wages for scarce skilled labor but also training time, quality issues during the learning curve, and productivity losses.

The compounding effect: Labor shortages force overtime premium payments, reduce production flexibility, and create bottlenecks that ripple through operations—all costs that standard accounting captures poorly.

Manufacturing advisory brief: To mitigate these risks, leaders should adopt proactive workforce planning, invest in automation and knowledge transfer, and implement cost visibility tools that reveal the true impact of labor shortages on operational performance.

Strategic Cost Optimization: Building Financial Intelligence

Effective manufacturing advisory services don’t start with “cut costs by 10%.” They start by understanding where value is created and destroyed in your operation, and then build financial intelligence into decision-making.

Real-Time Production Cost Visibility

Traditional approach: Wait until the month-end close, review variance reports, discover problems from three weeks ago, and implement fixes that won’t show results for two months.

Advisory approach: Daily visibility into production costs by job, product line, and customer. When margins trend wrong, you know immediately—while you have time to intervene.

Manufacturers implementing real-time costing catch margin-destroying issues 15-20 days earlier than with traditional monthly reporting. That’s the difference between fixing a problem and explaining a bad quarter.

Make-vs-Buy Analysis That Reflects Reality

Current process: Most manufacturers evaluate make-vs-buy decisions using standard costs that fail to capture the full picture. What gets overlooked: setup time, quality inspection costs, inventory carrying costs, engineering support, and opportunity cost of capacity.

Advisory insight: Many manufacturers discover they’re making components in-house because “we’ve always done it” when outsourcing would improve margins. Conversely, some find they’re outsourcing work they should bring in-house because they’ve underestimated total outsourcing costs.

Capital Investment Decisions Driven by Financial Impact

Production ask: Your production team wants new equipment because it’s faster or more automated. But will it actually improve profitability?

The analysis manufacturers need: Compare fully-loaded cost of capital investment (including installation, training, maintenance, increased overhead) against measurable financial benefit (reduced labor, improved quality, higher throughput, faster changeovers).

Manufacturing advisory services help quantify these trade-offs before you spend capital—not after, when you’re defending questionable ROI to your board.

Technology That Drives Financial Intelligence

Let’s talk about using tech to work smarter.

ERP Systems That Support Decision-Making

Your ERP collects data. A manufacturing advisory partner turns data into actionable financial intelligence:

• Job costing captures true profitability by customer and product
• Activity-based costing models reflecting actual production economics
• Variance analysis identifying root causes, not symptoms
• Forecasting tools connecting operational plans to financial outcomes

Implementation reality: Most manufacturers use about half of their ERP’s financial capabilities. Advisory partners help unlock more—without replacing systems or expensive customizations.

Business Intelligence That Answers Strategic Questions

CEOs need insights, not reports. Manufacturing advisory builds dashboards answering questions that matter:

• Which customers are profitable after accounting for service costs and complexity?
• Which products should we prioritize when capacity is constrained?
• Where are we creating value versus destroying it?
• What operational changes would drive the biggest margin improvement?

Building Financial Accountability in Operations

The best manufacturing advisory engagements don’t just optimize costs—they change how organizations think about the relationship between operations and financial performance.

When Engineering Understands Cost Impact

Design decisions have massive cost implications. Manufacturing advisory creates visibility into what design changes cost in setup time, material waste, and production disruption—enabling engineers to make decisions with margin awareness, not just technical performance.

The outcome: Engineers make design decisions that balance technical performance with margin awareness.

When Production Planning Drives Profitability

Production schedulers optimize for on-time delivery and utilization—important but insufficient. Manufacturing advisory helps them understand which orders generate the highest contribution margin per hour, where to invest capacity, and how batch sizes and changeover sequences affect total costs.

The transformation: Production planning becomes profit optimization, not just scheduling.

When Sales Teams Price for Actual Costs

Your sales team prices based on “market rates”—fine until you win money-losing business. Manufacturing advisory gives sales tools to understand true costs: what customer-specific customization costs, which accounts have hidden service costs, and where you can add value that customers will pay for.

The result: Sales organizations pursuing profitable revenue, not just volume.

When to Bring In Manufacturing Advisory Expertise

You need manufacturing advisory services when:

Financial signals:

• Gross margins are declining, but you can’t identify specific causes
• Some products seem profitable, while the overall business struggles
• Pricing decisions feel like guesswork rather than data-driven
• You’re winning bids that turn unprofitable

Operational indicators:

• Production metrics look good, but financial performance is weak
• You suspect some customers destroy value, but can’t quantify it
• Different departments can’t agree on what’s profitable

Strategic inflection points:

• Preparing for sale or seeking investment
• Launching new product lines or entering new markets
• Facing increased competition and margin pressure

Why Wiss for Manufacturing Advisory

At Wiss, we understand manufacturing operations. Our advisory team works with manufacturers across distribution, CPG, and industrial sectors, helping build financial intelligence into production operations.

Ready to understand what your production operations actually cost—and what they should cost? Contact our manufacturing advisory team to discuss optimizing production costs without sacrificing the quality that built your business.

---