Bylaws are the operating manual nobody reads until something goes wrong. Then everyone discovers they require monthly board meetings nobody’s been holding, or they prohibit email voting that the board’s been using for three years.
Here’s what your nonprofit bylaws actually need to accomplish—and what causes problems later.
What Bylaws Are (And Aren’t)
Bylaws are your nonprofit’s internal governance rules. They’re not filed with the state, but the IRS requires them for 501(c)(3) applications. They determine how your board operates, how decisions get made, and what happens when conflicts arise.
Bylaws aren’t your policies and procedures manual. Don’t put programming details, hiring processes, or operational workflows in bylaws. Those belong in separate policy documents you can update without formal amendment procedures.
Essential Bylaw Provisions
Let’s break it down.
Article I: Organization Name and Purpose
State your official legal name and reference your 501(c)(3) exempt purposes. Keep this broad—specific program details change, but your general charitable purpose shouldn’t.
Standard language: “The organization is organized exclusively for charitable and educational purposes under Section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code.”
Article II: Board of Directors Structure
Specify board size (minimum and maximum), term lengths, and term limits if any.
Practical consideration: Don’t require a large board if you can’t realistically recruit that many committed members. “5-15 board members” provides flexibility as your organization grows.
Most nonprofits use three-year terms with the option for one consecutive renewal, preventing board stagnation while retaining institutional knowledge.
Article III: Board Meetings
Define meeting frequency, notice requirements, and quorum.
Common mistake: Requiring monthly meetings when your volunteer board can realistically manage quarterly meetings. Write bylaws matching actual capacity, not aspirational governance.
The standard quorum is the majority of board members. Some organizations use one-third for operational flexibility, but this allows decisions to be made without board input.
Address remote participation: “Board members may participate via telephone or videoconference and such participation constitutes presence for quorum and voting purposes.”
Article IV: Officers
Identify required officer positions (typically President, Secretary, Treasurer), their duties, selection process, and terms.
Most states require at a minimum a President and a Secretary. The same person can hold multiple offices, except the President and the Secretary simultaneously (someone must witness the President’s signature on official documents).
Article V: Committees
Outline standing committees (Executive, Finance, Governance) and the process for creating additional committees.
Critical detail: Specify whether committees have decision-making authority or advisory roles only. Confusion here creates conflict when committees believe they’ve approved something the full board hasn’t endorsed.
Article VI: Conflict of Interest
Include your conflict of interest policy or reference it as a separate document.
IRS expectation: Board members must disclose conflicts annually, recuse themselves from related discussions and votes, and document these actions in meeting minutes.
Article VII: Amendment Procedures
Define how bylaws can be amended—typically requiring advance notice and a two-thirds vote.
Never make amendments so difficult that necessary changes don’t happen. “30 days’ written notice and unanimous vote” sounds protective but prevents responsive governance.
Common Bylaw Pitfalls
Overly specific requirements you’ll violate. Requiring the Secretary to mail physical meeting notices 14 days in advance made sense in 1985. In practice, everyone uses email now, but your bylaws technically prohibit it.
Rigid committee structures for small organizations. Three-person boards don’t need Executive, Finance, or Governance Committees. Committee of the Whole works fine until you grow.
Missing provisions for virtual operations. Many older bylaws require in-person meetings, with no virtual participation options. Post-pandemic, remote attendance has become standard practice requiring explicit bylaw authorization.
Compensation restrictions that prevent reasonable payments. Some bylaws prohibit any board member compensation. If you later want to hire your board treasurer as a part-time bookkeeper, you’ll need bylaw amendments plus an IRS private benefit analysis.
What Good Bylaws Look Like
Simple language. Your board members shouldn’t need lawyers to understand governance rules. “The board meets quarterly” beats “The Board of Directors shall convene in formal session no fewer than four times annually.”
Operational flexibility. Use ranges rather than fixed numbers: “5-15 board members,” not “exactly 9 board members.” Allow “at least quarterly” meetings rather than “third Tuesday of each month.”
Realistic requirements. Write bylaws reflecting how your organization actually operates, not theoretical best practices. A volunteer board managing a $200,000 budget doesn’t need monthly meetings and six standing committees.
Clear authority delegation. Specify which decisions require board approval and which require executive director authority. Ambiguity here creates either board micromanagement or staff overreach.
Template Structure
Here’s a basic outline covering standard provisions:
Article I: Name and Purpose
Article II: Board Composition and Structure
Article III: Board Meetings (frequency, notice, quorum)
Article IV: Officers (roles, election, terms)
Article V: Committees
Article VI: Executive Director (if applicable)
Article VII: Conflict of Interest
Article VIII: Financial Management
Article IX: Amendment Procedures
Article X: Dissolution
State-specific requirements vary. Some states mandate specific provisions; others provide default rules if bylaws don’t address certain issues.
When to Review and Revise Bylaws
Annually: Confirm current operations align with bylaw requirements. If you’re consistently ignoring provisions, amend the bylaws rather than continuing violations.
When governance changes—adding new officer positions, expanding the board, creating standing committees—formalize these in the bylaws rather than operating informally.
Before major transitions: Executive director departures, board leadership changes, or significant growth often reveal governance gaps. Update bylaws proactively during stable periods rather than reactively during a crisis.
Strategic Advisory for Nonprofit Governance
Bylaws that work require balancing legal compliance, operational reality, and organizational stage. Early-stage nonprofits need flexibility to adapt quickly. Mature organizations need a structure preventing board drift and ensures continuity.
Most nonprofits draft bylaws once during formation, then discover years later that growth has outpaced their governance structure. Strategic advisory helps boards recognize when governance documents need updating and how to structure amendments that support rather than constrain mission delivery.
Wiss provides advisory services to nonprofit boards navigating governance structure, bylaw development, and compliance requirements—ensuring your governance documents support effective leadership rather than creating administrative obstacles.
Questions about nonprofit bylaws or governance structure? Contact Wiss to discuss advisory support for your organization.
Previous
Share
