Most people start nonprofits because they’re passionate about solving a problem—poverty, education gaps, environmental damage, and healthcare access. Then they discover that passion doesn’t exempt them from paperwork, governance requirements, or IRS compliance.
Starting a nonprofit isn’t complicated, but it is a sequential process. Skip steps or get documents wrong, and you’ll spend months fixing preventable mistakes. Here’s what actually needs to happen.
Step 1: Clarify Your Mission and Confirm It Qualifies
Before filing anything, write one sentence describing what your organization will do and who it will serve. This becomes your mission statement and determines whether you qualify for 501(c)(3) status.
The IRS recognizes specific exempt purposes: charitable, religious, educational, scientific, literary, testing for public safety, fostering amateur sports competition, or preventing cruelty to children or animals. Your mission must fit one of these categories.
The founder wants to start a nonprofit supporting local artists by providing studio space and selling their work. This doesn’t qualify as charitable—it primarily benefits individual artists rather than serving a broad public purpose. Restructuring the mission to provide free art education to underserved youth would qualify.
If your purpose is advocacy or lobbying, you likely want a 501(c)(4) social welfare organization instead. If it’s a mutual benefit (serving members rather than the public), you’re looking at different exemption categories. Get this wrong initially, and you’ll reapply later.
Step 2: Choose Your State and Incorporate
Nonprofits are state-level corporations before they’re federal tax-exempt organizations. You’ll file articles of incorporation (or a certificate of formation) with your state’s business filing office—usually the Secretary of State.
Critical requirements for your articles of incorporation:
- Official name (check state database for availability and consider reserving it)
- Registered agent with a physical address in your state
- Statement of purpose limited to Section 501(c)(3) activities
- Dissolution clause directing assets to another 501(c)(3) if you dissolve
- No private inurement language (profits can’t benefit individuals)
That dissolution clause trips up most founders. Without language guaranteeing assets transfer to another exempt organization upon dissolution, the IRS will reject your 501(c)(3) application. Include specific wording like: “Upon dissolution, assets shall be distributed to one or more organizations exempt under Section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code.”
Most states charge $50-150 in filing fees. Processing takes 1-4 weeks depending on state backlog.
Step 3: Get Your EIN From the IRS
An Employer Identification Number (EIN) is your organization’s tax ID. You need it to open bank accounts, hire employees, and file your 501(c)(3) application.
Apply online at IRS.gov—it’s free and takes 15 minutes. You’ll receive your EIN immediately. Don’t pay third-party services charging $50-200 for something the IRS provides at no cost.
Step 4: Draft Bylaws That Match Your Operating Reality
Bylaws are your internal operating rules. They’re not filed with the state, but the IRS requires them for 501(c)(3) applications.
Essential bylaw provisions:
- Board size, structure, and term limits
- Officer roles and duties
- Meeting frequency and quorum requirements
- Voting procedures
- Conflict of interest policy
- Amendment procedures
Founders typically draft bylaws requiring monthly board meetings, then discover their volunteer board can’t commit to that schedule. Three months later, they’re operating in violation of their own bylaws. Be realistic about what your board can actually do.
Standard requirements: minimum three board members who aren’t related by blood or marriage, annual meetings, and compensation policies preventing private benefit.
Step 5: Recruit Your Initial Board of Directors
You need at least three unrelated individuals willing to serve as board members. Most states allow the same person to hold multiple officer positions (president, secretary, treasurer), but board diversity strengthens governance and improves IRS application outcomes.
Board composition matters for IRS review. A board consisting entirely of family members raises red flags about private benefit. A board with relevant professional expertise (accountants, lawyers, industry experts) demonstrates operational capability.
Your board should have formal conflict-of-interest policies and complete conflict-of-interest disclosure forms annually—the IRS specifically asks about this on Form 1023.
Step 6: Apply for 501(c)(3) Tax-Exempt Status
File Form 1023 (Application for Recognition of Exemption) or Form 1023-EZ if you qualify for the streamlined version. Form 1023-EZ is available only to organizations with projected annual gross receipts of $50,000 or less and assets of $250,000 or less.
Form 1023 requires
- Complete organizational documents (articles of incorporation, bylaws)
- Detailed narrative describing past, present, and planned activities
- Financial projections for three years (or actual financials if operating)
- Board member information and conflict of interest policies
- Compensation arrangements for officers and key employees
- User fee ($600 for organizations projecting over $10,000 annual revenue, $275 for smaller organizations)
The IRS takes 3-6 months to process applications, sometimes longer if they request additional information. Applications are public documents—anyone can request copies after approval.
Common rejection reasons
- Insufficient detail in activity descriptions
- Governing documents missing required dissolution language
- Financial projections appearing unrealistic or unsubstantiated
- Activities suggesting private benefit or substantial non-exempt purpose
- Inadequate conflict of interest policies
If approved, your exemption is retroactive to your incorporation date (assuming you filed within 27 months). If you miss that deadline, the exemption starts when you file Form 1023.
Step 7: Register at the State Level
State registration requirements vary significantly. Most states require:
- Charitable solicitation registration (if you’re fundraising)
- State tax exemption applications (separate from federal)
- Annual report filings with the Attorney General or Secretary of State
Some states require registration before soliciting donations; others have de minimis exemptions for donations raised below specific thresholds. Penalties for non-compliance include fines and the loss of the ability to legally solicit donations.
Step 8: Establish Financial Systems and Compliance Infrastructure
Once you’re operational, you need systems that support ongoing compliance:
Accounting requirements
- Separate bank account for organizational funds
- Fund accounting to track restricted vs. unrestricted donations
- Receipt systems for donor acknowledgment (required for gifts over $250)
- Books adequate for preparing Form 990 annually
Governance requirements
- Annual board meetings with documented minutes
- Regular financial reviews and approval of budgets
- Conflict of interest disclosure procedures
- Document retention policies
Organizations with revenues over $200,000 or assets over $500,000 may eventually need audited financial statements (varies by state). Even smaller organizations benefit from properly established accounting systems early—retrofitting systems to support audits or grant compliance later costs exponentially more.
The Advisory Support Most Founders Underestimate
Founders typically spend 80% of their energy on mission and 20% on structure. Successful nonprofits invert that ratio during formation—getting structure right initially prevents expensive corrections later.
The issues aren’t technical complexity; they’re knowing which details matter. Dissolution clauses, conflict-of-interest policies, board composition, and financial projections that align with stated activities—these determine whether your application gets approved in months or kicked back for revisions.
Strategic advisory support during formation helps founders avoid the three most expensive mistakes: governing documents requiring later amendments, financial systems inadequate for Form 990 preparation, and governance structures that don’t match operational reality.
Wiss provides advisory services to nonprofit founders navigating formation requirements, ensuring your structure supports both IRS compliance and mission effectiveness from day one.
Questions about starting a nonprofit or need guidance on the formation process? Contact Wiss to discuss advisory support for your organization.
Previous
Share
