Is Your ERP System Already Obsolete? The 36% Problem

                                       

By: Wiss Team

Wiss Team

A recent Censuswide survey of 4,295 global executives delivered an uncomfortable statistic: 36% believe the traditional ERP model will soon become obsolete, replaced by composable, modular, API-driven architectures. Another 33% think it’ll evolve with AI integration, while only 30% believe incremental enhancements will suffice.

That leaves a lot of CFOs staring at seven-figure ERP investments, wondering what comes next.

The Reality Check

The traditional ERP promise was elegant: one system integrates everything, eliminates data silos, and standardizes processes across the organization. One vendor, one implementation, one source of truth.

The reality involved multi-year implementations, budget overruns, and systems so rigid that simple business process changes required vendor consultants at $300/hour to modify configuration tables. Now that the model is being questioned—not by analysts pushing next-generation software, but by the executives running companies that depend on these systems.

According to IT Brew, ERPs are quietly becoming “glorified databases,” while the actual work is done elsewhere—in specialized applications, AI agents, and custom tools that users actually want to use. The ERP still stores data, but its infrastructure is no longer a solution.

Two Very Different Problems

You probably fall into one of these two camps.

If You’ve Already Invested Millions in ERP

You can’t rip out a system that runs your business. Too much institutional knowledge is embedded in configurations. Too many integrations. Too much risk.

But you also can’t ignore that the architecture is becoming less relevant. Here’s what we’re seeing work at Wiss:

Strategic augmentation, not replacement. The path forward isn’t abandoning your ERP—it’s treating it as the data layer while building capability around it. AI agents can orchestrate workflows across systems more effectively than monolithic platforms. Specialized applications can handle functions where your ERP falls short.

Systematic evaluation of what stays, what goes. Not every business process needs to live in the ERP. Finance leaders we work with are asking: which capabilities require specialized solutions and which can operate adequately with generic ERP functionality? This isn’t a one-time decision—it’s a gradual migration strategy.

Bridge technologies that extend life. Rather than massive re-implementation, we’re helping clients deploy integration layers, automation tools, and AI capabilities that make existing ERPs more functional without replacing them wholesale. The goal is to extract value from sunk costs while building future flexibility.

Real TCO analysis without vendor bias. Most companies dramatically underestimate the total cost of ownership—not just licensing and maintenance, but IT resources devoted to keeping it running, productivity lost to complexity, and opportunities missed because the system can’t adapt quickly enough. We help quantify that honestly.

If You Haven’t Implemented an ERP Yet

You have an advantage: you’re not committed to legacy architecture. But you also face a harder question—what’s the right tech stack when the traditional answer is becoming obsolete?

Start with the platform, not the system. Rather than selecting an ERP, evaluate platforms that let you build or integrate applications. This shifts the question from “which vendor” to “which foundation gives us flexibility.”

Composable architecture with realistic assessment. Best-of-breed approaches sound appealing—select optimal solutions for each function, connect via APIs. In practice, you’re trading vendor lock-in for integration complexity. This works if you have the technical sophistication to manage distributed systems. If you don’t, composability creates new problems.

The build vs. buy calculus has changed. Platform-as-a-service models let companies build custom applications rather than buy comprehensive software. But this requires development capabilities most organizations lack. We help clients honestly assess whether they can execute this approach or need more traditional solutions.

Finance is the integration point. Your financial system becomes the hub that connects specialized applications rather than the monolith that does everything. We’re helping clients structure tech stacks in which finance serves as the system of record, while operations, sales, and other functions use tools designed for their workflows.

The AI Factor We Need to Address (Honestly)

Every ERP vendor claims AI capabilities. Most are selling automation of manual processes or smarter search—useful, but not transformative.

The actual disruption: agentic AI that can autonomously execute multi-step workflows across systems. When agents can query your financial system, check procurement history, analyze inventory, and generate purchase orders without human intervention—what value does ERP-native functionality provide?

This isn’t speculation. Organizations with technical capability are implementing this now. The ERP becomes a data repository that the agent updates, not the application users. That fundamentally changes what you need from enterprise software.

What Wiss Actually Does About This

We’re not selling software or implementations. We’re helping finance leaders navigate this transition based on their actual situation:

For existing ERP clients: Develop migration strategies that balance operational continuity with necessary evolution. Evaluate which AI and automation tools genuinely extend system value versus vendor marketing. Model scenarios for gradual transition versus wholesale replacement.

For pre-implementation clients: Assess organizational capacity to realistically execute alternatives. Structure tech stacks that provide flexibility without creating unmanageable complexity. Connect finance leaders with technology partners who understand the changing landscape.

For everyone: Provide an honest total cost of ownership analysis that includes hidden costs most companies miss. Help translate vendor claims into operational reality. Develop financial models to support technology decisions using real business cases.

Technology Strategy Without the Sales Pitch

Whether you’re managing existing ERP investments or evaluating alternatives, technology decisions require a realistic assessment of organizational capabilities, an honest total cost analysis, and operational migration strategies that actually work. Wiss’s Technology Advisory Services help CFOs navigate these decisions based on what you can execute, not what vendors want to sell.

Schedule a consultation to discuss your specific situation—no vendor agenda, just advisory.

This article references IT Brew’s analysis of ERP evolution and provides a strategic perspective on technology architecture decisions. It does not constitute specific implementation recommendations. Wiss & Company LLP provides accounting, tax, and advisory services to companies evaluating enterprise technology investments.           

Previous"Understanding Contribution Margin in Manufacturing Operations"